In a decision that has important ramifications for the life sciences industry, on January 28, 2013, in Caldwell ex rel State of Louisiana v. Janssen Pharmaceutical, Inc., (No. 2012-C-2447, No. 2012-C-2466), the Supreme Court of Louisiana, by a 4–3 vote, reversed a $330 million trial court award against Janssen Pharmaceutica, Inc., and entered final judgment in Janssen’s favor. Under the theory of liability that had been pursued by Louisiana at trial, virtually any public statement about any product that might be subject to Medicaid reimbursement could be subject to civil penalties totaling hundreds of millions of dollars—on a state-by-state basis—even if the statement was not made as part of a claim for reimbursement and there was no proof that the providers who wrote prescriptions for it did so for any reason other than a medical determination the product was the more … Read More »